Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sam Kramer's avatar

(As always), this was an epic post, David. Thank you for sharing! Kryznaric's "being a good ancestor" quote is indeed a very cool description.

I was an Ag student at Cornell (’18) and while I pursued an "interdisciplinary major" (so I could enroll in more AEM courses), my focus was on environmental sciences and natural resources.

I become interested in environmental studies after reading "Ishmael" by Daniel Quinn, a popular environmentalist / catastrophist early 90s novel that inspired a lot of young folks (like me) to pursue a course of study (and for some, a career!) related to the environment.

Obviously, today I'm no longer on that career path nor am I focused on the environment. I can still talk your ears off about el nino southern oscillation or how the (diminishing) density of the antarctic current is going to remix our climate over the next few generations, but my day job / work isn’t related to combating climate change.

I’m sharing this background because sometimes I imagine - say 20 years from now - gifting a copy of Ishmael with my combative anti-establishment teenage daughter and then her asking me why mom and dad didn’t “do more” to combat climate change when we were young.

Of course, the real answer is “it’s super complicated sweetie, you’ll understand better as you enter adulthood,” but in the moment, I’ll probably respond to her with “look, mom and I did our best. We were early adopters of EVs, we made our house as efficient as possible, and we were even vigilant about offsetting our footprint because we flew around a lot for travel and to visit grandma.”

Little will she know, that in the early 2020s, “being vigilant about offsetting our footprint” just meant downloading + paying an app like Klima and calling it a day...

A few follow up questions:

1. Do you feel like you’re being a good ancestor? If there are ever moments when you don’t and if so, how do you react/handle that? Is it *really possible* to be a good (or perfect) ancestor?*

2. I can understand how being a successful searcher and entrepreneur COULD make you a “good ancestor” (assuming stellar behavior outside of your profession) for your *immediate* descendants, (assuming you provide them with lives of meaning AND means), but what about "for the world that comes after you?"

3. Now I’ve gotta ask - what is your North Star? What is that “one unattainable goal” you are marching towards?

*I’m sure another fellow Cornell alum, Thomas Midgley felt like (and died believing) that he was a “good ancestor.” He was the inventor of leaded gasoline and CFCs - (simplifying here but), thanks to good ole Thomas today we live with 100x more lead in our bloodstream than humans 100 years ago and it turns out that CFCs are absolutely terrible for the environment...

On the other hand, refrigeration was a pretty stellar invention and we probably wouldn't have experienced such significant health improvements without it.

How should we assess *how good* of an ancestor Midgley was? Of course it's not binary, but he died completely unaware of the future negative impacts of his inventions - can we blame him for that part of his legacy? Just a thought.

Expand full comment

No posts